Before the Steelers Signed Aaron Rodgers, They Had Their Eyes on Two Other QBs
The Pittsburgh Steelers’ acquisition of Aaron Rodgers sent shockwaves throughout the NFL, marking a bold new chapter for the storied franchise. While the focus has been on the future Hall of Famer donning black and gold, few know that the Steelers’ journey to secure a top-tier quarterback included serious considerations of two other names before landing Rodgers.
A Franchise in Transition
The departure of long-time quarterback Ben Roethlisberger left the Steelers with a significant void under center. The 2022 and 2023 seasons saw the team experimenting with various options, but none seemed to capture the spark needed to lead the team back to championship contention. Determined to make a bold move, the Steelers’ front office began exploring marquee options in the quarterback market.
First Choice: Russell Wilson
Before Rodgers entered the picture, the Steelers reportedly had their sights set on Russell Wilson, the former Seattle Seahawks and Denver Broncos quarterback. Wilson’s track record as a Super Bowl champion and his dynamic playmaking ability made him an attractive option. The Steelers admired his mobility, leadership qualities, and experience in high-pressure situations.
However, Wilson’s hefty price tag and Denver’s reluctance to part with their quarterback proved to be significant hurdles. Negotiations stalled as it became clear that acquiring Wilson would require sacrificing multiple high draft picks and young talent—a price the Steelers were unwilling to pay.
Second Consideration: Derek Carr
Another quarterback who caught the Steelers’ attention was Derek Carr, who had recently been released by the Las Vegas Raiders. Carr’s availability as a free agent made him an appealing, cost-effective option. Known for his consistency, Carr brought a reputation for being a reliable leader and a team-first player.
The Steelers’ interest in Carr reportedly advanced to discussions with his representatives. However, concerns emerged about whether his ceiling as a quarterback was high enough to contend in a division loaded with star signal-callers, including Joe Burrow and Lamar Jackson. The front office ultimately decided to aim higher, leaving Carr to sign with the New Orleans Saints.
The Rodgers Deal
When Aaron Rodgers became available, the Steelers’ strategy shifted dramatically. Negotiating with the Green Bay Packers, Pittsburgh’s management recognized the rare opportunity to secure a quarterback with Rodgers’ pedigree. Despite his age and the Packers’ steep asking price, the Steelers believed Rodgers could provide the veteran leadership and elite skill set necessary to elevate the team to contender status.
The trade package was substantial, including two first-round picks, a second-rounder, and a promising young defensive player. Yet, the Steelers’ willingness to go all-in signaled their commitment to winning now.
Looking Ahead
Rodgers’ arrival has reignited hope among Steelers fans and injected a sense of urgency into the organization. With a solid roster that boasts a strong defense and a budding offense, the addition of a quarterback of Rodgers’ caliber could be the final piece of the puzzle.
While the journey to this blockbuster acquisition had its twists and turns, the Steelers’ bold moves reflect an organization determined to reclaim its place among the NFL’s elite. As the season unfolds, only time will tell if Rodgers can deliver the results the Steelers’ faithful are hoping for.